The lights dim. The orchestra swells. A shadow crosses the stage. Somewhere in the dark, a scream turns into a song.

Welcome to Broadway’s spookiest season, where the magic of live theatre meets the mysteries of the night. This Halloween, skip the haunted house and step into the theater district — where spirits dance, villains sing, and the chills come with curtain calls.

From gothic tales and dark comedies to cult classics that defined generations, here’s the Savvy Seats guide to Broadway After Dark — your ticket to the most haunting, hysterical, and hypnotic shows of the season.

The Addams Family

Dark, droll, and deliciously dysfunctional — The Addams Family musical is the perfect blend of macabre charm and family chaos. Gomez, Morticia, and Wednesday take the stage in a hilarious story about love, loyalty, and living unapologetically strange.

“When you’re an Addams, every night feels like Halloween — just with better lighting.”

Savvy Seats Tip: A perfect choice for families or groups who enjoy clever humor and gothic charm. Find Addams Family tickets.

Beetlejuice

It’s showtime. Again. Beetlejuice is back for a limited Broadway engagement, and he’s louder, funnier, and deader than ever. Expect outrageous humor, twisted visuals, and a soundtrack that makes the afterlife feel like a party.

“The afterlife’s favorite troublemaker is back, and he’s dying to meet you.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Ideal for a Halloween weekend plan that’s equal parts chaotic and comedic. Get Beetlejuice tickets.

Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors

Broadway gets a bloody good time with Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors — a witty, fast-paced spin on the classic vampire tale. This production combines gothic grandeur with laugh-out-loud modern humor, making it as unpredictable as it is entertaining.

“Part gothic grandeur, part stand-up chaos — and it slays every time.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Perfect for date night or anyone who loves their horror with a punchline. Find Dracula tickets.

Ghost: The Musical

Romance never dies — and in Ghost: The Musical, neither does love. Adapted from the iconic film, this supernatural story blends emotional ballads, cinematic visuals, and haunting performances that will stay with you long after the curtain falls.

“A love so strong, not even death can bring down the curtain.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Ideal for couples looking for a heartfelt yet haunting night out. Book Ghost seats.

Little Shop of Horrors

Feed me, Seymour. Little Shop of Horrors remains one of Broadway’s most beloved cult classics — a perfect mix of camp, chaos, and killer music. Between the laugh-out-loud moments and that iconic carnivorous plant, it’s the kind of show you’ll never forget.

“Catchy songs, creepy laughs, and the most dangerous houseplant in show business.”

Savvy Seats Tip: See it off-Broadway for the full, intimate experience. Find Little Shop tickets.

The Phantom of the Opera

The legend continues — just not in New York, for now. The Phantom of the Opera is currently captivating audiences in London’s West End, but it’s set to return to the United States in November 2025. Expect the same sweeping romance, candlelit catacombs, and haunting score that made it the longest-running musical in Broadway history.

“Masks fall, hearts race, and the music of the night still echoes across oceans.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Join the waitlist and be the first to know when U.S. dates are announced. Track Phantom tickets.

The Rocky Horror Show

Nothing defines Halloween quite like The Rocky Horror Show. This cult classic brings audience participation, wild costumes, and unapologetic chaos to the stage. It’s the ultimate interactive experience for those who believe theater should be loud, outrageous, and unforgettable.

“It’s not a show. It’s a ritual.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Midnight performances sell out fast. Book Rocky Horror seats.

Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

Blood, vengeance, and brilliant storytelling come together in Sweeney Todd, one of Broadway’s darkest masterpieces. With a haunting score and razor-sharp performances, it’s a tale of revenge that cuts deep — both literally and emotionally.

“Justice is served… with a side of pie.”

Savvy Seats Tip: For the full theatrical immersion, choose orchestra seats near the action. Get Sweeney Todd tickets.

Wicked

Not all witches are wicked. Wicked remains a Broadway powerhouse — a dazzling reimagining of Oz that explores friendship, power, and perception. It’s equal parts heart and spectacle, and it’s the perfect way to channel your inner witch this Halloween.

“Not all villains are evil — some just need better PR.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Aim for mezzanine seats to experience the full magic of “Defying Gravity.” Find Wicked tickets.

Young Frankenstein

“It’s alive!” Mel Brooks’ Young Frankenstein is a musical comedy that brings the dead to life in the most hilarious way possible. Expect tap-dancing monsters, lightning bolts, and enough gags to make you forget it’s technically a horror story.

“Brains, bolts, and belly laughs — the perfect Halloween combination.”

Savvy Seats Tip: Grab your group and make it a night of laughter and lightning.Check Young Frankenstein tickets.

Curtain Call: Broadway Is the New Haunted House

Whether you crave gothic love stories, supernatural comedies, or pure Halloween spectacle, Broadway delivers the kind of thrills no haunted maze can match. Each show offers its own brand of magic — part mystery, part music, all unforgettable.

There are no tricks here, just front-row treats. Explore the full lineup of Halloween and fall shows at SavvySeats.com — and claim your seats before they disappear into the dark.